Sankhya yoga - Bhagvat Gita
I have started reading Bhagvat Gita.
I am going through Chapter-2 in which Shri Krishna explains Sankhya Yoga to Arjuna.
I would like to understand exactly what the Sankhya Yoga means ?
What is Sankhya Yoga ?
Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ?
What is its importance ?
What does it means ?
bhagavad-gita
New contributor
add a comment |
I have started reading Bhagvat Gita.
I am going through Chapter-2 in which Shri Krishna explains Sankhya Yoga to Arjuna.
I would like to understand exactly what the Sankhya Yoga means ?
What is Sankhya Yoga ?
Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ?
What is its importance ?
What does it means ?
bhagavad-gita
New contributor
You are asking too many questions. Your question may be closed as "too broad".
– The Destroyer♦
3 hours ago
Apologies for that but seriously the term is itself broad. It will be great if you could edit the question to make it more meaningful.
– Shivkumar Mallesappa
2 hours ago
I think "Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ? And What is its importance ?" are same. Also "Sankhya Yoga means ? And What does it means ? And Sankhya Yoga means ?" Same. Right?
– Krishna Shweta
2 hours ago
1
Don't get it confused with the ancient school of philosophy called Sankhya. A translation in this instance of chapter 2 is 'Knowledge'.
– Swami Vishwananda
1 hour ago
@SwamiVishwananda yes, absolutely.
– commonman
16 mins ago
add a comment |
I have started reading Bhagvat Gita.
I am going through Chapter-2 in which Shri Krishna explains Sankhya Yoga to Arjuna.
I would like to understand exactly what the Sankhya Yoga means ?
What is Sankhya Yoga ?
Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ?
What is its importance ?
What does it means ?
bhagavad-gita
New contributor
I have started reading Bhagvat Gita.
I am going through Chapter-2 in which Shri Krishna explains Sankhya Yoga to Arjuna.
I would like to understand exactly what the Sankhya Yoga means ?
What is Sankhya Yoga ?
Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ?
What is its importance ?
What does it means ?
bhagavad-gita
bhagavad-gita
New contributor
New contributor
New contributor
asked 5 hours ago
Shivkumar MallesappaShivkumar Mallesappa
1162
1162
New contributor
New contributor
You are asking too many questions. Your question may be closed as "too broad".
– The Destroyer♦
3 hours ago
Apologies for that but seriously the term is itself broad. It will be great if you could edit the question to make it more meaningful.
– Shivkumar Mallesappa
2 hours ago
I think "Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ? And What is its importance ?" are same. Also "Sankhya Yoga means ? And What does it means ? And Sankhya Yoga means ?" Same. Right?
– Krishna Shweta
2 hours ago
1
Don't get it confused with the ancient school of philosophy called Sankhya. A translation in this instance of chapter 2 is 'Knowledge'.
– Swami Vishwananda
1 hour ago
@SwamiVishwananda yes, absolutely.
– commonman
16 mins ago
add a comment |
You are asking too many questions. Your question may be closed as "too broad".
– The Destroyer♦
3 hours ago
Apologies for that but seriously the term is itself broad. It will be great if you could edit the question to make it more meaningful.
– Shivkumar Mallesappa
2 hours ago
I think "Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ? And What is its importance ?" are same. Also "Sankhya Yoga means ? And What does it means ? And Sankhya Yoga means ?" Same. Right?
– Krishna Shweta
2 hours ago
1
Don't get it confused with the ancient school of philosophy called Sankhya. A translation in this instance of chapter 2 is 'Knowledge'.
– Swami Vishwananda
1 hour ago
@SwamiVishwananda yes, absolutely.
– commonman
16 mins ago
You are asking too many questions. Your question may be closed as "too broad".
– The Destroyer♦
3 hours ago
You are asking too many questions. Your question may be closed as "too broad".
– The Destroyer♦
3 hours ago
Apologies for that but seriously the term is itself broad. It will be great if you could edit the question to make it more meaningful.
– Shivkumar Mallesappa
2 hours ago
Apologies for that but seriously the term is itself broad. It will be great if you could edit the question to make it more meaningful.
– Shivkumar Mallesappa
2 hours ago
I think "Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ? And What is its importance ?" are same. Also "Sankhya Yoga means ? And What does it means ? And Sankhya Yoga means ?" Same. Right?
– Krishna Shweta
2 hours ago
I think "Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ? And What is its importance ?" are same. Also "Sankhya Yoga means ? And What does it means ? And Sankhya Yoga means ?" Same. Right?
– Krishna Shweta
2 hours ago
1
1
Don't get it confused with the ancient school of philosophy called Sankhya. A translation in this instance of chapter 2 is 'Knowledge'.
– Swami Vishwananda
1 hour ago
Don't get it confused with the ancient school of philosophy called Sankhya. A translation in this instance of chapter 2 is 'Knowledge'.
– Swami Vishwananda
1 hour ago
@SwamiVishwananda yes, absolutely.
– commonman
16 mins ago
@SwamiVishwananda yes, absolutely.
– commonman
16 mins ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
According to Sridhara Swami, the meaning of the SAnkhya-Yoga of Bhagavat-Gita is as follows (Ref: Commentary of Gita, 2/39).
सम्यक् ख्यायते प्रकाश्यते वस्तुतत्त्वमनयेति संख्या सम्यग्ज्ञानं तस्मिन्प्रकाशमानमात्मतत्त्वं सांख्यं
samyak khyApate prakAshyate vastutattvam anayA iti samkhyA samyakjnAnam tasmin prakAshamAnam atmatattvam sAnkhyam.
Meaning:By which the Knowledge of the Self is properly revealed is called sankhyA.The yoga related to sankhyA is called SAnkhya-Yoga.
Acharya Sankar also reveals the same meaning :
[SAnkya means] the standpoint of Self-realization, with regard to the discriminating knowledge of the supreme Reality.
The same meaning has been derived by Acharya Ramanuja also:
Sankhya' means 'intellect,' and the truth about the Atman, which is determinable by the intellect, is 'Sankhyam.
Other commentators like Madhusudan Saraswati also connote the same implication :
सांख्ये सम्यक्ख्यायते सर्वोपाधिशून्यतया प्रतिपाद्यते परमात्मतत्त्वमनयेति संख्योपनिषत्तयैव तात्पर्यपरिसमाप्त्या प्रतिपाद्यते यः स सांख्यः। sAnkhye samyak khyAyate sarva-upAdhisunyatayA prtipadyte paramatmatattvam anayA iti sankhyopanishat tayA eva tatparyaparisamAptyA oratipAdyate.
So to conclude, the SAnkhya-Yoga of the Gita is the Yoga that reveals proper expression of the knowledge of the Supreme Self.
By the way, this SAnkhya-Yoga has nothing to do with the SAnkhya Philosophy propounded by Kapila Muni. Kapila Muni did not accept the concept of God as the existence of God can not be proved and so His philosophy is not being referred to in the Gita, which is based on the concept of God.
One would expect sAmkhya to mean Kapila's sAmkhya. I am in general distrustful of vedAntins talking about the meaning of sAmkhya.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber SAnkhya of Gita can NOT be Kapil's sAnkhya because Kapil does not accept the existence of God and Gita is the Song of God:)
– commonman
2 hours ago
There is a theistic sAmkhya also, found in Mahabharata.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber The Sankhya of MB is definitely not Kapil's view! So what is the diff. between that and what the Acharyas have mentioned?
– commonman
1 hour ago
In my opinion, sAmkhya, anywhere in Mahabharata, is Kapila's sAmkhya (theistic version) only. Kapila in Mahabharata is an incarnation of Vishnu.
– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago
|
show 1 more comment
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
According to Sridhara Swami, the meaning of the SAnkhya-Yoga of Bhagavat-Gita is as follows (Ref: Commentary of Gita, 2/39).
सम्यक् ख्यायते प्रकाश्यते वस्तुतत्त्वमनयेति संख्या सम्यग्ज्ञानं तस्मिन्प्रकाशमानमात्मतत्त्वं सांख्यं
samyak khyApate prakAshyate vastutattvam anayA iti samkhyA samyakjnAnam tasmin prakAshamAnam atmatattvam sAnkhyam.
Meaning:By which the Knowledge of the Self is properly revealed is called sankhyA.The yoga related to sankhyA is called SAnkhya-Yoga.
Acharya Sankar also reveals the same meaning :
[SAnkya means] the standpoint of Self-realization, with regard to the discriminating knowledge of the supreme Reality.
The same meaning has been derived by Acharya Ramanuja also:
Sankhya' means 'intellect,' and the truth about the Atman, which is determinable by the intellect, is 'Sankhyam.
Other commentators like Madhusudan Saraswati also connote the same implication :
सांख्ये सम्यक्ख्यायते सर्वोपाधिशून्यतया प्रतिपाद्यते परमात्मतत्त्वमनयेति संख्योपनिषत्तयैव तात्पर्यपरिसमाप्त्या प्रतिपाद्यते यः स सांख्यः। sAnkhye samyak khyAyate sarva-upAdhisunyatayA prtipadyte paramatmatattvam anayA iti sankhyopanishat tayA eva tatparyaparisamAptyA oratipAdyate.
So to conclude, the SAnkhya-Yoga of the Gita is the Yoga that reveals proper expression of the knowledge of the Supreme Self.
By the way, this SAnkhya-Yoga has nothing to do with the SAnkhya Philosophy propounded by Kapila Muni. Kapila Muni did not accept the concept of God as the existence of God can not be proved and so His philosophy is not being referred to in the Gita, which is based on the concept of God.
One would expect sAmkhya to mean Kapila's sAmkhya. I am in general distrustful of vedAntins talking about the meaning of sAmkhya.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber SAnkhya of Gita can NOT be Kapil's sAnkhya because Kapil does not accept the existence of God and Gita is the Song of God:)
– commonman
2 hours ago
There is a theistic sAmkhya also, found in Mahabharata.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber The Sankhya of MB is definitely not Kapil's view! So what is the diff. between that and what the Acharyas have mentioned?
– commonman
1 hour ago
In my opinion, sAmkhya, anywhere in Mahabharata, is Kapila's sAmkhya (theistic version) only. Kapila in Mahabharata is an incarnation of Vishnu.
– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago
|
show 1 more comment
According to Sridhara Swami, the meaning of the SAnkhya-Yoga of Bhagavat-Gita is as follows (Ref: Commentary of Gita, 2/39).
सम्यक् ख्यायते प्रकाश्यते वस्तुतत्त्वमनयेति संख्या सम्यग्ज्ञानं तस्मिन्प्रकाशमानमात्मतत्त्वं सांख्यं
samyak khyApate prakAshyate vastutattvam anayA iti samkhyA samyakjnAnam tasmin prakAshamAnam atmatattvam sAnkhyam.
Meaning:By which the Knowledge of the Self is properly revealed is called sankhyA.The yoga related to sankhyA is called SAnkhya-Yoga.
Acharya Sankar also reveals the same meaning :
[SAnkya means] the standpoint of Self-realization, with regard to the discriminating knowledge of the supreme Reality.
The same meaning has been derived by Acharya Ramanuja also:
Sankhya' means 'intellect,' and the truth about the Atman, which is determinable by the intellect, is 'Sankhyam.
Other commentators like Madhusudan Saraswati also connote the same implication :
सांख्ये सम्यक्ख्यायते सर्वोपाधिशून्यतया प्रतिपाद्यते परमात्मतत्त्वमनयेति संख्योपनिषत्तयैव तात्पर्यपरिसमाप्त्या प्रतिपाद्यते यः स सांख्यः। sAnkhye samyak khyAyate sarva-upAdhisunyatayA prtipadyte paramatmatattvam anayA iti sankhyopanishat tayA eva tatparyaparisamAptyA oratipAdyate.
So to conclude, the SAnkhya-Yoga of the Gita is the Yoga that reveals proper expression of the knowledge of the Supreme Self.
By the way, this SAnkhya-Yoga has nothing to do with the SAnkhya Philosophy propounded by Kapila Muni. Kapila Muni did not accept the concept of God as the existence of God can not be proved and so His philosophy is not being referred to in the Gita, which is based on the concept of God.
One would expect sAmkhya to mean Kapila's sAmkhya. I am in general distrustful of vedAntins talking about the meaning of sAmkhya.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber SAnkhya of Gita can NOT be Kapil's sAnkhya because Kapil does not accept the existence of God and Gita is the Song of God:)
– commonman
2 hours ago
There is a theistic sAmkhya also, found in Mahabharata.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber The Sankhya of MB is definitely not Kapil's view! So what is the diff. between that and what the Acharyas have mentioned?
– commonman
1 hour ago
In my opinion, sAmkhya, anywhere in Mahabharata, is Kapila's sAmkhya (theistic version) only. Kapila in Mahabharata is an incarnation of Vishnu.
– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago
|
show 1 more comment
According to Sridhara Swami, the meaning of the SAnkhya-Yoga of Bhagavat-Gita is as follows (Ref: Commentary of Gita, 2/39).
सम्यक् ख्यायते प्रकाश्यते वस्तुतत्त्वमनयेति संख्या सम्यग्ज्ञानं तस्मिन्प्रकाशमानमात्मतत्त्वं सांख्यं
samyak khyApate prakAshyate vastutattvam anayA iti samkhyA samyakjnAnam tasmin prakAshamAnam atmatattvam sAnkhyam.
Meaning:By which the Knowledge of the Self is properly revealed is called sankhyA.The yoga related to sankhyA is called SAnkhya-Yoga.
Acharya Sankar also reveals the same meaning :
[SAnkya means] the standpoint of Self-realization, with regard to the discriminating knowledge of the supreme Reality.
The same meaning has been derived by Acharya Ramanuja also:
Sankhya' means 'intellect,' and the truth about the Atman, which is determinable by the intellect, is 'Sankhyam.
Other commentators like Madhusudan Saraswati also connote the same implication :
सांख्ये सम्यक्ख्यायते सर्वोपाधिशून्यतया प्रतिपाद्यते परमात्मतत्त्वमनयेति संख्योपनिषत्तयैव तात्पर्यपरिसमाप्त्या प्रतिपाद्यते यः स सांख्यः। sAnkhye samyak khyAyate sarva-upAdhisunyatayA prtipadyte paramatmatattvam anayA iti sankhyopanishat tayA eva tatparyaparisamAptyA oratipAdyate.
So to conclude, the SAnkhya-Yoga of the Gita is the Yoga that reveals proper expression of the knowledge of the Supreme Self.
By the way, this SAnkhya-Yoga has nothing to do with the SAnkhya Philosophy propounded by Kapila Muni. Kapila Muni did not accept the concept of God as the existence of God can not be proved and so His philosophy is not being referred to in the Gita, which is based on the concept of God.
According to Sridhara Swami, the meaning of the SAnkhya-Yoga of Bhagavat-Gita is as follows (Ref: Commentary of Gita, 2/39).
सम्यक् ख्यायते प्रकाश्यते वस्तुतत्त्वमनयेति संख्या सम्यग्ज्ञानं तस्मिन्प्रकाशमानमात्मतत्त्वं सांख्यं
samyak khyApate prakAshyate vastutattvam anayA iti samkhyA samyakjnAnam tasmin prakAshamAnam atmatattvam sAnkhyam.
Meaning:By which the Knowledge of the Self is properly revealed is called sankhyA.The yoga related to sankhyA is called SAnkhya-Yoga.
Acharya Sankar also reveals the same meaning :
[SAnkya means] the standpoint of Self-realization, with regard to the discriminating knowledge of the supreme Reality.
The same meaning has been derived by Acharya Ramanuja also:
Sankhya' means 'intellect,' and the truth about the Atman, which is determinable by the intellect, is 'Sankhyam.
Other commentators like Madhusudan Saraswati also connote the same implication :
सांख्ये सम्यक्ख्यायते सर्वोपाधिशून्यतया प्रतिपाद्यते परमात्मतत्त्वमनयेति संख्योपनिषत्तयैव तात्पर्यपरिसमाप्त्या प्रतिपाद्यते यः स सांख्यः। sAnkhye samyak khyAyate sarva-upAdhisunyatayA prtipadyte paramatmatattvam anayA iti sankhyopanishat tayA eva tatparyaparisamAptyA oratipAdyate.
So to conclude, the SAnkhya-Yoga of the Gita is the Yoga that reveals proper expression of the knowledge of the Supreme Self.
By the way, this SAnkhya-Yoga has nothing to do with the SAnkhya Philosophy propounded by Kapila Muni. Kapila Muni did not accept the concept of God as the existence of God can not be proved and so His philosophy is not being referred to in the Gita, which is based on the concept of God.
edited 17 mins ago
answered 2 hours ago
commonmancommonman
10.8k751
10.8k751
One would expect sAmkhya to mean Kapila's sAmkhya. I am in general distrustful of vedAntins talking about the meaning of sAmkhya.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber SAnkhya of Gita can NOT be Kapil's sAnkhya because Kapil does not accept the existence of God and Gita is the Song of God:)
– commonman
2 hours ago
There is a theistic sAmkhya also, found in Mahabharata.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber The Sankhya of MB is definitely not Kapil's view! So what is the diff. between that and what the Acharyas have mentioned?
– commonman
1 hour ago
In my opinion, sAmkhya, anywhere in Mahabharata, is Kapila's sAmkhya (theistic version) only. Kapila in Mahabharata is an incarnation of Vishnu.
– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago
|
show 1 more comment
One would expect sAmkhya to mean Kapila's sAmkhya. I am in general distrustful of vedAntins talking about the meaning of sAmkhya.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber SAnkhya of Gita can NOT be Kapil's sAnkhya because Kapil does not accept the existence of God and Gita is the Song of God:)
– commonman
2 hours ago
There is a theistic sAmkhya also, found in Mahabharata.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber The Sankhya of MB is definitely not Kapil's view! So what is the diff. between that and what the Acharyas have mentioned?
– commonman
1 hour ago
In my opinion, sAmkhya, anywhere in Mahabharata, is Kapila's sAmkhya (theistic version) only. Kapila in Mahabharata is an incarnation of Vishnu.
– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago
One would expect sAmkhya to mean Kapila's sAmkhya. I am in general distrustful of vedAntins talking about the meaning of sAmkhya.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
One would expect sAmkhya to mean Kapila's sAmkhya. I am in general distrustful of vedAntins talking about the meaning of sAmkhya.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber SAnkhya of Gita can NOT be Kapil's sAnkhya because Kapil does not accept the existence of God and Gita is the Song of God:)
– commonman
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber SAnkhya of Gita can NOT be Kapil's sAnkhya because Kapil does not accept the existence of God and Gita is the Song of God:)
– commonman
2 hours ago
There is a theistic sAmkhya also, found in Mahabharata.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
There is a theistic sAmkhya also, found in Mahabharata.
– Lazy Lubber
2 hours ago
@LazyLubber The Sankhya of MB is definitely not Kapil's view! So what is the diff. between that and what the Acharyas have mentioned?
– commonman
1 hour ago
@LazyLubber The Sankhya of MB is definitely not Kapil's view! So what is the diff. between that and what the Acharyas have mentioned?
– commonman
1 hour ago
In my opinion, sAmkhya, anywhere in Mahabharata, is Kapila's sAmkhya (theistic version) only. Kapila in Mahabharata is an incarnation of Vishnu.
– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago
In my opinion, sAmkhya, anywhere in Mahabharata, is Kapila's sAmkhya (theistic version) only. Kapila in Mahabharata is an incarnation of Vishnu.
– Lazy Lubber
1 hour ago
|
show 1 more comment
You are asking too many questions. Your question may be closed as "too broad".
– The Destroyer♦
3 hours ago
Apologies for that but seriously the term is itself broad. It will be great if you could edit the question to make it more meaningful.
– Shivkumar Mallesappa
2 hours ago
I think "Why the lord tries to make Arjuna understand Sankhya Yoga ? And What is its importance ?" are same. Also "Sankhya Yoga means ? And What does it means ? And Sankhya Yoga means ?" Same. Right?
– Krishna Shweta
2 hours ago
1
Don't get it confused with the ancient school of philosophy called Sankhya. A translation in this instance of chapter 2 is 'Knowledge'.
– Swami Vishwananda
1 hour ago
@SwamiVishwananda yes, absolutely.
– commonman
16 mins ago